You are currently viewing
<span class="bsf-rt-reading-time"><span class="bsf-rt-display-label" prefix="Reading Time"></span> <span class="bsf-rt-display-time" reading_time="5"></span> <span class="bsf-rt-display-postfix" postfix="mins"></span></span><!-- .bsf-rt-reading-time -->Simple vs. Exponential Moving Averages: Which Is Better for Crossovers?

Simple vs. Exponential Moving Averages: Which Is Better for Crossovers?

In the world of trading, Moving Averages play a pivotal role. They help traders identify trends, potential entry and exit points, and can serve as reliable indicators of market direction. Among the various types of moving averages, two of the most commonly used are the Simple Moving Average (SMA) and the Exponential Moving Average (EMA).

In this blog, I’ll share insights from my own trading experience to help you understand the differences between these two moving averages and determine which is better for crossovers, a crucial aspect of technical analysis.


Table of Contents


SMA VS EMA

Simple Moving Averages (SMA) – The Basics

To kick things off, let’s dive into the world of Simple Moving Averages (SMA). As the name suggests, SMAs are simple to calculate and understand. They are a straightforward arithmetic mean of a specific number of closing prices over a defined period.

The Simple Moving Average is a straightforward calculation that involves summing up a set number of closing prices and dividing by the number of periods.

SMA = (Sum of Closing Prices for the Selected Days) / (Number of Days)

For example, to calculate a 25-day SMA, you would add up the closing prices of the last 10 days and then divide by 25. This creates a smooth line on a price chart that represents the average price over a specified time period.

Advantages of SMAs:

  • Simplicity: SMAs are incredibly easy to calculate. You sum up the closing prices for a specific period and divide by the number of data points.
  • Smooth Trends: SMAs smooth out price data, which can help identify the overall trend direction without getting distracted by minor price fluctuations.
  • Reliability: SMAs are less sensitive to short-term price movements, making them reliable indicators of longer-term trends.

Now, let’s delve into an example to see how SMAs can be useful for crossovers. Imagine you’re looking at a daily chart of a popular stock, and you’ve plotted a 50-period SMA alongside a 200-period SMA.

Here’s how the crossover works:

Scenario 1: Bullish Crossover (Golden Cross)

When the 50-period SMA crosses above the 200-period SMA, it’s called a “Golden Cross.” This is a strong bullish signal, indicating that a long-term uptrend may be beginning.

SMA Golden cross
Source : Trading View

Scenario 2: Bearish Crossover (Death Cross)

Conversely, when the 50-period SMA crosses below the 200-period SMA, it’s known as a “Death Cross.” This is a strong bearish signal, suggesting a long-term downtrend may be emerging.

SMA death cross

Now, let’s shift our attention to Exponential Moving Averages (EMAs).

Exponential Moving Averages (EMA) – The Dynamic Alternative

EMAs, as the name implies, give more weight to recent prices, making them more responsive to current market conditions. They are calculated by assigning a multiplier to the most recent price data, which decreases exponentially as you move back in time.

The Exponential Moving Average gives more weight to recent prices, making it more responsive to recent market movements compared to the SMA.

It is calculated using a formula that places greater emphasis on the most recent data points. As a result, the EMA reacts quickly to price changes and is favoured by traders who want to capture short-term trends.

EMA (today) = [Closing Price (today) – EMA (yesterday)] * Multiplier + EMA (yesterday)

*Multiplier = [2 / ((Number of days) + 1)]

Advantages of EMAs:

  • Sensitivity: EMAs react faster to price changes, which can be an advantage for traders looking for short-term trading opportunities.
  • Timely Signals: Due to their responsiveness, EMAs often generate crossover signals earlier than SMAs, providing traders with potentially more timely entry and exit points.
  • Effective in Trending Markets: EMAs are particularly effective in trending markets, where they can help traders capitalize on the momentum.

Here’s a real-life example to illustrate how EMAs work. Imagine you’re trading a cryptocurrency like Bitcoin and have plotted a 10-period EMA alongside a 30-period EMA.

Scenario 1: Bullish EMA Crossover

When the 10-period EMA crosses above the 30-period EMA, it generates a bullish signal, indicating a potential uptrend. This earlier signal can be advantageous for short-term traders.

EMA Golden cross

Scenario 2: Bearish EMA Crossover

Conversely, if the 10-period EMA crosses below the 30-period EMA, it produces a bearish signal, suggesting a potential downtrend. Again, this earlier signal can be helpful for short-term traders aiming to profit from downward movements.

Ema death cross

Which Is Better for Crossovers?

The million-dollar question: Which moving average is better for crossovers – SMA or EMA? Well, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. The choice largely depends on your trading style, risk tolerance, and the specific market conditions you’re trading in.

Here is a short guide on when to use EMA & SMA-

When to Use SMAs:

  • Long-Term Investors: If you’re a long-term investor looking to identify and stay in major trends, SMAs can be a solid choice. They provide reliable signals, and you won’t be whipsawed by short-term fluctuations.
  • Reduced Noise: SMAs are excellent for reducing noise in your charts, making it easier to focus on the bigger picture.
  • Positional Traders: SMAs are a better fit for traders with a longer time horizon who can afford to wait for confirmation of a trend.

When to Use EMAs:

  • Short-Term Traders: If you’re an active day or swing trader, EMAs might be more suitable. They provide quicker signals, allowing you to act on shorter-term price movements.
  • Trend Followers: EMAs excel in trending markets, making them ideal for traders who want to ride the momentum of a trend.
  • Risk Takers: Traders who are comfortable with more sensitivity and potential false signals might prefer EMAs, but they need to be ready to manage the increased risk.

Finding the Right Balance

In many cases, traders find that using both SMAs and EMAs can be beneficial. The SMA helps provide a broader context of the market trend, while the EMA provides precise entry and exit signals. It’s all about finding the right balance for your specific trading strategy.

Let me share a personal trading experience to highlight this choice. A few months ago, I was trading a popular tech stock – Microsoft , I used a combination of the 10-period EMA and the 50-period SMA on a daily chart.

Microsoft stock moving average strategy
Source: Investing

The EMA provided me with timely entry and exit signals, which allowed me to capture quick profits in the volatile tech sector. On the other hand, I also had a 200-period SMA on my chart to identify the long-term trend. This combination helped me balance short-term trades with a broader market perspective.

Here are some key takeaways:

  1. Understand Your Trading Style: Your trading style, whether long-term or short-term, should drive your choice of moving average.
  2. Risk Tolerance Matters: Consider how comfortable you are with potentially more signals (EMAs) versus fewer but more reliable ones (SMAs).
  3. Combine Both: It’s often beneficial to combine both SMAs and EMAs on your charts to get a comprehensive view of the market.
  4. Backtest Your Strategy: Before implementing any moving average crossover strategy, backtest it thoroughly to ensure it aligns with your goals and risk tolerance.
  5. Stay Informed: Keep a close eye on market conditions, news, and economic events. Moving averages are just one tool in your trading arsenal, and they should be used in conjunction with other analysis techniques.

In conclusion, the choice between Simple Moving Averages (SMA) and Exponential Moving Averages (EMA) depends on your trading style, goals, and risk tolerance. SMAs are reliable and ideal for longer-term traders, while EMAs are more responsive and suitable for short-term and momentum traders. Combining both types of moving averages can provide a balanced approach to your trading strategy, giving you the best of both worlds.

Another approach for utilizing moving averages is the Triple Moving Average Crossover method. Exploring different combinations of three moving averages can yield valuable insights. I invite you to experiment with this strategy and share your experiences in utilizing moving averages.

Remember, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer, so it’s essential to understand how these moving averages work and which one suits your trading needs.

Check Moving Averages in Trading View-

Author

  • RUPIN JOSHI

    Rupin Joshi Senior Technical Analyst, Finance Writer, and Trading ExpertRupin Joshi is a seasoned Trading Expert with over a decade of experience. As a prolific Finance Writer, he has authored numerous research papers in Technical Analysis and Price Action. Rupin's insights and strategies have earned him global recognition, including awards in Trading Competitions. Currently serving as the Director at Bulls Arena Trading, he continues to empower traders and investors with his expertise and innovative approaches.

Candlestick Patterns Trading Course